Technology

Italy Fines Meta $887 Million Over Facebook Photo Access

Italy has fined Meta 805 million euros, about $887 million, after finding that the Facebook app on Android phones accessed Italian users’ photos without their specific consent. The Garante, Italy’s data protection authority, announced the penalty on Saturday, 14 November 2026, and said it was the largest fine it had ever imposed.

The case centres on a Facebook feature that suggests photos and videos from a phone’s gallery while a person browses the app. According to the regulator, the feature was switched on by default, and the app’s consent process was too vague for users to understand what they had agreed to. About 20 million Android users in Italy were affected.

In this article:

Italy Fines Meta: What the Garante Found

Colosseum in Rome, Italy, where the Garante announced the Meta fine.
Photo: Wilfredor / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

The Garante said the Facebook app on Android devices accessed photos, videos and associated metadata stored on Italian users’ smartphones without specific consent and without informing them properly. The finding covers the feature called “Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook”, which shows people photos and videos from their own gallery as suggestions to post while they scroll. Al Jazeera reported that the regulator also criticised Meta’s lack of cooperation during the investigation.

The regulator’s objection was not only about access. It said the app asked for gallery access through a single permission covering the whole app and several different functions, while the notice shown to users did not mention gallery suggestions at all. In the Garante’s view, that kind of broad consent is not valid consent, because users could not fully understand what they were allowing.

The feature has been available since 2023, enabled by default, and the Garante noted the violation was still ongoing for users who had not updated the app. That combination, a default-on setting plus a vague explanation, is at the heart of this facebook photo privacy ruling.

Key factDetail
RegulatorGarante, Italy’s data protection authority
Company finedMeta Platforms Ireland Ltd
Fine805 million euros (about $887 million)
AnnouncedSaturday, 14 November 2026
Users affectedAbout 20 million Android users in Italy
Legal basisArticle 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, implementing the EU ePrivacy Directive

How the Facebook Gallery Feature Worked

woman using a smartphone while the Facebook app suggests photos from her gallery.
Photo: Nenad Stojkovic / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

The feature is simple on the surface. While a person browses Facebook, the app suggests photos and videos from the phone’s gallery that the person might want to post. The idea is to make sharing faster by surfacing recent pictures while someone is already using the app.

Behind that convenience sits the Facebook gallery access the Garante objected to: to make the suggestions, the app could reach into the gallery, including photos, videos and metadata, without specific consent and without properly telling users.

The investigation began in July 2025, after a complaint from the Consumer Protection Centre of Bolzano, and the Garante then carried out its own technical analysis of the app.

One question the case did not answer is whether any gallery content was used to train artificial intelligence models. The Garante said its proceedings did not cover that question, and Meta denies such use. A newer feature, launched in 2026, that processes gallery content in the cloud may be assessed separately.

Why the Fine Is So Large

At 805 million euros, the penalty is by far the largest the Garante has ever imposed. The meta fine 887 million penalty equals about 0.47 percent of Meta’s global turnover.

Several factors pushed the amount up. The first was scale: roughly 20 million Android users in Italy fell within the affected group. The second was duration: the feature had been running since 2023 and the violation was still ongoing. The third was conduct: the Garante pointed to Meta’s lack of cooperation and to an earlier violation that had already resulted in a fine in 2019. The regulator did count Meta’s late changes after the Bolzano complaint as a mitigating factor.

The Garante applied Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive rather than the GDPR, so the case stayed in Italy instead of going to Ireland’s regulator. That makes the garante meta fine a test of how far a national regulator can go under ePrivacy law.

What Meta Must Do in the Next 60 Days

The fine is only half of the decision. Meta now has 60 days to fix the feature.

First, the gallery suggestions feature must be switched off by default. Second, Meta must ask users for separate, specific consent before turning it on for anyone. Third, the company must explain clearly what the feature does, say that it needs gallery access, and tell users how to switch it off.

Notably, the fix applies even to people who already granted the broad app permission. Those users must still be asked again, separately, before the feature can run for them.

Meta’s Response and the Appeal

Meta strongly disagrees with the decision and has said it will appeal, calling the fine disproportionate. A Meta spokesperson defended the feature as a simple tool that helps people share photos and videos on Facebook.

“This is a simple feature that helps people share photos and videos on Facebook. Users must grant permission on their device before the feature can operate, and they can change that permission at any time in their settings,” the spokesperson said in a statement reported by AP.

That position clashes directly with the Garante’s finding, which is that a device-level permission plus a vague in-app notice does not amount to the specific, informed consent the law requires.

Meta is no stranger to costly legal fights. The company recently reached Meta and TikTok teen settlements worth millions of dollars per teenager in social media addiction cases.

What the Ruling Means for Facebook Users

For most Facebook users outside Italy, nothing changes immediately. The ruling applies to Italian Android users, and the required fix is limited to that group. But the reasoning behind it could travel further, because other European regulators watch the Garante’s decisions closely, and the ePrivacy rules apply across the European Union.

The case is also a warning to every app developer that a phone’s photo gallery is treated as private space. The Garante described the smartphone as part of a person’s private sphere, a framing likely to shape future cases about app permissions. Regulators are not the only check on large technology companies: voters have also had a direct say, including in recent data centre ballot measures in the United States.

For users, the practical lesson is to review app permissions from time to time. On Android, the Facebook app’s photo permission can be checked in the phone’s settings, and gallery suggestions can be switched off inside the app. Big technology services have faced repeated disruption and scrutiny this year, from the recent Microsoft 365 outage to fresh privacy rulings like this one.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much did Italy fine Meta?

Italy fined Meta Platforms Ireland Ltd 805 million euros, about $887 million. The Garante announced the meta italy privacy fine on 14 November 2026 and said it was the largest penalty it had ever imposed.

What did Facebook do wrong?

The Facebook app on Android accessed photos, videos and metadata in Italian users’ galleries without specific consent. The gallery suggestions feature was on by default, and the consent process was too generic.

How many people were affected?

About 20 million Android users in Italy were affected, according to the regulator. The feature had been available since 2023.

Did Facebook use the photos to train AI?

The Garante said its proceedings did not examine that question. Meta denies using the content for AI training.

What happens next?

Meta has 60 days to switch the feature off by default and seek separate, specific consent from users in Italy. The company has said it will appeal the decision, calling the fine disproportionate.

Conclusion

The $887 million fine is a record for Italy’s data protection authority, and it draws a firm line around the photos on people’s phones. A helpful feature, switched on by default and explained vaguely, was not enough to count as consent in the Garante’s eyes.

Whether the penalty survives Meta’s appeal remains to be seen, but the ruling already sends a message across the technology industry: access to a user’s gallery needs a clear explanation and a specific yes. For Facebook users in Italy, that change should arrive within 60 days.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *